Weekly Poll: Are You Impressed by Google Now?

Those of you with a Nexus device (or one of the few other phones and tablets with an official Jelly Bean update or unofficial ROM) have surely already tried out Google Now. What do you think of it?

I hate to say it, but I’m a little disappointed — it doesn’t feel ready yet. I was really interested to read Joe’s recent post outlining Google Now, as his experiences don’t match mine.

Part of the issue is that I’m in the UK. I had to fiddle around with the locality settings to switch from the old robot to the new voice in the first place, which was not a good start. And although Google Now understands my asking “When are the Cubs playing?”, showing me a card of the latest scores and giving me updates periodically from then on, it has no idea what I mean by “When is Manchester United playing?”, simply showing me a standard Google search result.

Okay, so it’s not international yet. That’s irritating, but understandable. Unfortunately, other little irritations exist, and they do add up. For instance, setting a reminder is useful, and I find myself doing it a lot: “In 15 minutes, remind me to take the vegetables out of the oven” successfully sets an alarm for fifteen minutes in the future, prompting me to “take the vegetables out of the oven.” Great! But these gradually fill up my stock Alarms list, so that it’s now full of odd times — and there’s no way to select several and delete them all. Plus, a request like “On Tuesday, remind me to do the recycling” brings up an error message, rather than setting an alarm, a calendar appointment, or a Google Task.

There are inconsistencies, too. Most voice actions are given as though talking to a person: “Remind me to X”, “What’s the weather like?”, “Navigate to X”. But “Play music” just loads the Google search results for [play music] (of which the first result is the Play Store listing for, yep, Play Music). To make the phone play music, I have to say, “Listen to music”. And even then it just loads a playlist of songs whose title contains the word “music”!

I could go on, but I won’t. I really like the idea of Google Now; I like the presentation, I like the concept – but it’s not ready yet. In time (and especially when other app developers build on top of it) I think it will be great. But for now, it’s just a novelty that’s more annoying that useful. Do you agree?


  • http://pixelswim.com Steve Heinrich

    I agree that the voice commands are not nearly ready yet. It is definitely a gimmick right now, as is Siri, but there is potential. The one thing I take from Google Now is that search at least looks a lot better and is smarter. I generally just type my search anyway because I am in the office and don’t want to seem crazy. The “outside of the browser” approach for things like image search is nice.

  • http://alexlovesjam.com Alex

    I live in the UK and bought a Nexus 7, after testing Google Now I have to agree with you. I don’t really follow sports so never use that feature, it would be cool if you could ask who won certain events at the Olympics (I haven’t tried this but I doubt it works). I’m really disappointed that I can’t add events or reminders to my calendar. I’m sure there’ll be more features added, until then I don’t really have a use for it.

  • banelicious

    I can feel your pain…I live in Italy so I face the same issues as you do.
    For me is even weirder to SPEAK in ENGLISH to my phone.

    I have my fingers crossed to Now being localized in Italian, but I highly doubt it.

    As far as random questions concerns,I just tried asking “who won the latest Olympics male fencing game” and I got a card with medals recap for fencing.

    Better than nothing,I guess

  • Pingback: 2012 in Android: A Retrospective | TKJ STEPIRO Brotherhood

  • Pingback: 2012 in Android: A Retrospective | Android.AppStorm

theatre-aglow
theatre-aglow
theatre-aglow
theatre-aglow